guardian.co.uk,
Helen Pidd in Munich, Wednesday 9 November 2011
Bernie Ecclestone has been a powerful voice in the sport of Formula 1 for four decades. Photograph: Vivek Prakash/Reuters |
He is one
of the richest men in the world with such a fierce reputation for
micro-managing his multibillion-pound business that he has been described as
"one of the most dictatorial men in world sport". On Wednesday, the
public were offered a rare glimpse into the workings of the billionaire's world
when Bernie Ecclestone the 81-year-old chief executive of Formula 1 was called
as a witness in what is being billed as the biggest corruption trial in Germany
since the second world war.
Though
Ecclestone is not in the dock, he is accused of giving a $44m (£27.5m) bribe to
an executive at a German state-owned bank in order to retain his iron rule over
the lucrative motor racing industry.
Despite
initially denying all knowledge of the payment now admits authorising the very
big transfer. But, he explained on Wednesday, he had made it because he was
being "shaken down", or blackmailed, by Gerhard Gribkowsky, the
53-year-old former chief risk officer of BayernLB, who is the one facing a
possible 15-year jail sentence.
Gribkowsky,
who has been in jail since his arrest in January, is on trial for accepting
this "corrupt" payment. He also faces charges of breach of trust and
tax evasion over his role in the 2005 sale of the bank's $839m (£526m) stake in
F1 to CVC, the private equity group.
Ecclestone,
it is alleged, was keen for the deal to go through because he knew CVC would
let him stay the top dog in motor spot.
For most
people, paying someone £27.5m would be a pretty big deal. Especially if they
didn't know the recipient terribly well and were not 100% sure what the payment
was for.
But not, it
seems, for Ecclestone. He admitted he had paid Gribkowsky the money, but only
because he feared the German might be about to tell the Inland Revenue that he
[Ecclestone] was secretly in charge of Bambino, an offshore family trust
controlled by his ex-wife, Slavika – a false allegation, said Ecclestone, which
could nonetheless lead to a tax investigation and a colossal bill.
"I
don't control the trust, but if the Revenue had investigated, the burden of
proof would have been on me to prove I wasn't," he said.
That would
have taken time he didn't have and money he didn't want to spend, he explained.
So he paid Gribkowsky to keep schtum. "I thought it might keep him quiet
and peaceful and friendly and stop him doing silly things," Ecclestone
told the court.
Gribkowsky
denies blackmailing Ecclestone and claims the payments he received were
legitimate F1 consultancy fees.
Ecclestone
was blasé about one source of his immense wealth – the $41.4m (£26m) commission
Gribkowsky paid him personally out of BayernLB funds for smoothing the F1 sale.
"I did a very, very good job," he shrugged. So good, in fact, that he
still feels cheesed off. "I thought I deserved more," he added.
Giving
evidence in a soft and occasionally croaky voice, Ecclestone admitted
Gribkowsky had never made an "open threat" to tip-off the Inland
Revenue. But he felt that the German was prepared to do so after Ecclestone
refused to go into business with him. He worried, he said, that Gribkowsky
could do "something a little bit vindictive".
"It
was a risk I couldn't afford to take," he said. How much could this risk
cost, asked the judge, Peter Noll. "In excess of £2bn," replied
Ecclestone.
He didn't
ever discuss a figure with Gribkowsky, he testified – a claim received with
incredulity by the judge. "You're seriously saying you were going to
transfer all that money without telling him so that he only discovered it when
he went to the cash machine and checked his balance?" he asked.
Yes,
insisted Ecclestone. "[Gribkowsky] wasn't the sort of person to say 'pay
me this or I'll do that' and I'm not the sort of person who says 'I'll pay you
this if you don't do that,'" he said.
Later he
likened the situation to "one of those gangster films where the gangsters
say 'we know where your children go to school and what route they take' and so
forth and you know exactly what they mean."
Gribkowsky
was "angry", said Ecclestone, after misunderstanding the English way
of negotiating.
"I
wouldn't like to say I misled him," said Ecclestone, referring to a
discussion that the two men had about going into business together, "but
being English, it's very difficult to say no to people. I say, 'let's think
about it.' Which in English is a very clear no. People don't always understand
that."
He just
organised the transfer, he said, and there was the unspoken agreement that he
and Gribkowsky would "decide later on what it [the $44m] was for".
Ecclestone
said that $18m (£13.2m) of the money was paid to Gribkowsky via his friend,
Flavio Briatore, a rich former owner of two F1 teams.
Briatore
knew the reason for the payment, said Ecclestone: "I said I was being
shaken down."
The case
continues.
Powerful
and controversial
Bernie Ecclestone, 81, born in Suffolk, the son of a trawlerman, has been a powerful
voice and an extremely hands-on supremo in Formula 1 for four decades. He left
school at 16 and first indulged a motorcycle hobby. Although he never made the
grade as a top car racer – twice retiring from the sport in the 1950s – by the
end of the 60s he was manager of Jochen Rindt, who won the F1 drivers'
championship posthumously in 1970, having crashed at the Italian circuit of
Monza.
Within a
couple of years, Ecclestone had bought the Brabham racing team and became a key
figure as he and other team leaders tried to gain control of TV rights. Brabham
had mixed success on the track under his leadership although the Brazilian
driver Nelson Piquet made his name in his car and won two world championships. He
sold the team in 1987.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.